Hall of Flame!

Hall of Flame! was started and maintained by John Langbridge, KB5NJD. When the web host made changes which disrupted John's extensive LF/MF web site in February, 2021, key portions of the site were transferred to other LF/MF operators who had web space available. Since I have always enjoyed Hall of Flame! I volunteered to host and maintain it. Please send any future submissions for Hall of Flame to me.   -Paul, N1BUG

At one time or another most MF and LF operators have had an accident with their antenna systems where fire was involved. As a member of this club, I can say that its never fun when something burns up as it usually happens in a difficult to reach and repair location. Below are images from a few members of this hallowed club. Check back regularly as I expect the offerings to grow over time.

December 30, 2020 addition: DF6NM had an accident on 2200 meter but fixed it in a flash!
February 10, 2021 addition: G4JNT shares details of an accident that occurred some years back. February 10, 2021 addition: IK1HSS shares interesting details about several past experiences.

Roger, VK4YB, recently submitted this offering which shows the awesome energy associated with 450-watts of RF power at a high voltage point on one of his end-fed antennas. Note that these antennas are supported at something like 100-foot above the ground so the branch that this wire was adjacent to must have burned up before the wire fell and did this damage.

Laurence, KL7L / WE2XPQ, provided this iconic picture a couple of years ago after a bolt (the one pictured), got too hot after being subjected to 55-amps of RF current at 137 kHz. Laurence repaired the ATU, which has traveled all over the world with him but the all-thread had to be replaced.

ADDITION 10/21/2019: Laurence reported an inductor failure in his 2200 meter low pass filter that had been running at power levels in excess of 1000 watts with no problems since 2003. Note the heating that deformed the enclosure.

Laurence also experienced a heating problem with a power supply that discolored a plastic carpet protector where the supply was sitting. There was a problem with the power supply and the transformer was replaced and returned to service.

ADDITION 12/23/19: Laurence reported an inductor failure in the 2200-meter antenna coupler (blue tub seen earlier) just days before Christmas. It seems that there was a lot of burning and flying debris in the tub based on the mess. Laurence believes that the ferrite is ok but he will have to re-wrap the coil with fiber glass tape and rewind the wire, placing the taps in their appropriate locations.

courtesy KL7L

Larry, W7IUV / WH2XGP, reports that this is what happens when “dirty ice” builds up inside the coil form. He indicates that the first picture is the covered coil while the second image shows the cover removed and the full extent of the damage.

(larger image)

(larger image)

John, KB5NJD, reports this event. "It occurred on a very cold January night in 2014. I can only imagine that the cold temperatures stiffened the plastic tubing I was using as an additional layer of protection with my PTFE-insulated high voltage leads off of the coil. The stiff tubing probably was stressed when I moved the variometer after a CW session back to WSPR. So much for extra protection! Fortunately the power supplies for the amplifiers responded to the over-current conditions and stopped the otherwise runaway event."

(larger image)

(larger image)

Neil, W0YSE/7 / WG2XSV, now located in Washington state, reports that “When in Utah, I had an incident happen at the base of my vertical antenna. I was “hot switching” the coax taps at the base of the loading coil and things went sour. I discovered this arc-over on the back side of my PVC “insulation”. I had to re-mount the base on a new PVC pipe to be able to transmit again on 630 meters.”

John, WA3ETD / WG2XKA, submitted this offering of one of his original 630-meter verticals: “At one point the TX vertical consisted of 35′ telescoping aluminum tubing, coupled to 2x, 100′ top wires on 4′ spreaders. The 2″ bottom section was insulated with a 1/8″ thick black PVC tube, clamped to a piece of 3/4″ pressure treated plywood, which in turn was clamped to an iron steam pipe. The PVC broke down and burned thru to the conductive copper sulphate plywood, as seen. The vertical now serves as my RX only vertical, no HV!”

Ralph, W5JGV / WD2XSH/7, submitted a large number of pictures that I sorted through to find three that I thought were the most dramatic. I suppose the “take home” message here is that PVC insulators will burn when ignited and it will generate chlorine gas that will corrode everything and potentially kill you in a very horrible way if you breath it. Most likely carbon tracking started the process off due to surface contaminants on the PVC. Ralph also reminds us that antennas and loading coils are not the only parts of the RF system that can burn as semiconductors will fail in dramatic fashion with fire, projectiles and noise. All we are missing is scorched earth!

Merv, K9FD/KH6 / WH2XCR, submitted the image below of fire that came thought the PVC base insulator of his low band vertical. Merv explains: “This is the base of my vertical, about 3 foot of gray electrical PVC conduit makes up the base insulator, 3 inch irrigation pipe makes the vertical… Was tuning and all was fine with low power, but at higher power the SWR kept going berserk. Could not find a problem until I walked around to look at the vertical and there was a huge black carbon trail.

Where you see the “strip” of clean in the black area is where a ground strap was before. Fire jumped through the PVC from the vertical to the ground strap, about 8 inches. I removed the ground strap. PVC is not the best insulator when it at a high voltage point. I changed the tuning circuit and cleaned off as much carbon as possible. Its ok now but needs to be changed at some time.”

Ben, N1VF, submitted these images showing a tree branch that he set ablaze with his vertical radiator followed by an image of his low pass filter that experienced a silver mica capacitor failure. While the filter failure ended Ben’s opening night operating session, at least the explosion was contain! Finally, Ben submitted a relay box where water had collected on top and arced over on the case while transmitting.

Paul, W0RW, reported that his BC-221, capable of operation down to 125 kHz, caught fire during a routine battery recharge. This was not a matter of simple flames, but more like six Estes rocket motors firing at the same time as Paul described it. The incident lead to the development of a battery temperature monitor that he now uses while changing. The complete story is recounted in the March 2018 issue of CQ magazine. Note that in spite of the fantastic visual at the time of the incident, there is not much to see so Paul staged an image that accurately depicts the incident, minus the mess from the fire extinguisher.

(larger image)

Jan, LA3EQ, submitted this gem which occurred following a storm, when “…the antenne lead jumped off the plastic isolator and came in contact with metal rod on house wall. This was me running wspr on 136kHz with 60 Watts…

(larger image)

Paul, N1BUG, shows just how fast things can turn sideways: “The transmitter had been running ~250W TPO almost 48 hours at 87% duty cycle at the time of failure. There was no warning, or at least none I recognized. Things looked fine on the ScopeMatch 20 minutes earlier but when I checked it again the system was far off resonance. I shut down and went out to look at the coil assembly. When I removed the coil enclosure cover, smoke came billowing out!

I can only speculate as to cause. The machine screw is a pass-through connection from a wire inside the coil form to the bottom of the coil shown. The nut on a similar pass-through at the other end of the coil was found to be loose but there is not yet any sign of heating on that one. I speculate this connection loosened up and subsequent heating caused the damage, possibly with an intermediate step of a shorted turn developing due to heating of the machine screw. I know from other experience that a shorted turn in the big coil causes very high current and significant heating.”

Brandy, N1HO, took a very formal and humorous approach to submitting his “application” for the Hall of Flame and I could not help but include the details in their entirety rather than simply summarizing:

“The undersigned humbly submits his application to the Hall of Flame Club, and respectfully submits as evidence of his stupidity and/or technical arrogance, optical photographs of the incident as described below. A waiver of the submission of realtime thermographic images is also requested as the applicant does not possess, nor has realistic access to, any thermographic observation equipment.

The attached photographs depict a #12 THHN wire connected from top of a matching coil to a PL-259 (“UHF”) connector affixed to the input connector (SO-239) of a 20m quarter-wave vertical antenna. A 46 foot (14m) wire is attached to the tip of this antenna, and is held horizontally by an avocado tree to the north. The aforementioned wire was wrapped with approximately 3 turns of white Scotch #35 electrical tape before insertion into the connector, where it was soldered. However, a combination of some recent adjustments to the physical alignment of this wire to assist with the tuning of the overall antenna system (in the parlance of the usersof the 630m amateur band, it is the “variometer” for this antenna), as well as the extended use of the applicant’s newly constructed amplifier, appears to have caused this incident. Said amplifier has a measured output of approximately 120W, and this antenna configuration had been successfully used at the more modest level of 25W for at least two months prior to this incident.

The applicant sheepishly admits that the construction and use of the antenna was entirely his own “work” and believes that no one else is potentially culpable. Indeed, he was warned the previous evening by the designer of the amplifier that the high current readings seen on the DC supply bus to the amplifier only when it was attached to the antenna system described above, was indeed a potential (pardon the pun) issue, which the applicant disregarded in the mistaken belief that the ammeter was defective.

Accordingly, the applicant begs the indulgence of the HOFC Admission Committee and approves this application.

Sincerely yours,
Bayard R. “Brandy” Coolidge, BSEE
Amateur Radio Station N1HO
26 March 2019″

Days later, Brandy found this at the end of the top loading wire:

02/06/20 UPDATE: Brandy found yet another way to start a fire with RF, this time burning through his Delrin insulator. Delrin is NOT an insulator at extremely high voltages and when contaminants accumulate on the surface so be careful when selecting insulating material!

courtesy N1HO

Tom, N9RU, reported that a plastic clip was holding the radiator lead just off of the coil and wasn’t quite long enough to avoid arcing to ground via the supporting nail and tree. The results can be seen below.

courtesy N9RU

Mike, W3TS, submitted the following slightly afflicted Tee-top insulator, noting that it was “… not up to the high voltage when wet and running 100 watts to the antenna. Tee top is now high quality glass insulators held up by the out rigger arm.

courtesy W3TS

UPDATE 9/13/2019: Mike originally located a loading coil at the top of the vertical section of his antenna and as often happens, the coil eventually arcing at 110 watts TPO, effectively ruining the coil (look for the black spot on the brown coil). Mike has now replaced this coil with a variometer at the base and more power applied to the antenna, which is a common approach for MF/LF where we are regulated by radiated power rules.

courtesy W3TS (larger image)

Update 9/25/2019: This didn’t take long… Submission number three is in the books.  110 watts TPO and this BC306 vario is toast:

(larger image)

Russ, KB8U, had a a bit of excitement while in a CW QSO with me (KB5NJD) on October 3. Russ explains:

“…My antenna had an abnormally high SWR of about 2:1 but in my excitement I decided to blast through it. I reduced power to about 80 watts output and made it through the QSO without the amplifier faulting to standby.

Discretion is the better part of valor but I just couldn’t resist (you’re only my second CW QSO on 630 meters). Today I found the culprit causing the high SWR. I use a 40 meter dipole fed as a marconi and have the vertical element (coax) held about a foot away from the base of the tower by some 1/2 inch CPVC pipes. Insects had built a nest inside the pipe and heavy rain made the goo inside the pipe conductive enough so that it was arcing to the the coax. Fortunately it was arcing where I happened to have a PL-259 coupler so I did not even have to repair the coax. I removed the not-so-insulating pipe, retaped the connector and I’m QRV again.”

courtesy KB8U

John, N2EIK, reported on the afternoon of October 6, 2019 that he has “Been down for a few nights. xmit & rcv went right down the pooper. What the heck? Today I finally had time to look. There was a poorly dressed coax that fell on top of the center conductor feed to the variometer. It arced through the coax insulation and shorted the 630m feed to ground. On the up-side, no damage was done to amps, etc. The green wire is the main feed to the antenna, the coax was for a scanner antenna. There is a wire nut(s) due to the switching arrangement in the feed. I can shunt out(bypass)the variometer so I can still use the inverted L on 80 & 160.

courtesy N2EIK

courtesy N2EIK

Eric, NO3M, submitted the following image of what can happen when using an underrated relay to switch the taps on an impedance transformer for his 2200 meter system. He added that “the worst part was when xyl called me in the middle of testing, locked up the remote access to station and couldn’t shut it down…. went 2 minutes arcing…” Good times…

courtesy NO3M

ADDITION 12/23/19: Eric had a second submission just days before Christmas as a panel on the wooden helix house ignited between the output insulator and the vacuum relay. While early reports are sketchy and require more analysis, he reported in darkness that “something in the wood siding is igniting due to the intense RF field or something… I found no failure in the insulator or the relay…

courtesy NO3M

courtesy NO3M

Ward, K7PO, offered the following before and after images and explanation:

This was the current transformer on the Delrin feedthru to the antenna. I think it was #77 or #78 ferrite. All was good on 630 and 2200 meters, but when I did some 8 khz work things went wrong. At 8 khz the core got hot enough to start the Delrin on fire…

courtesy K7PO

courtesy K7PO

Keith, K0KE, submitted the following images, noting that he was in the middle of a QSO with W7IUV when “…the big 2.5 mH coil arced to ground via a mounting tab that was attached to the cabinet which was grounded. It was on the hot antenna side of the coil running 75 w. I cleaned the coil and remounted it on ceramic standoffs with no further problems last nite.

courtesy K0KE

courtesy K0KE

David, N1DAY, burned up an automotive relay. He explains:

“…I hate to go outside in the winter to adjust my antenna settings, so everything is automated with 40A SPDT automotive relays which have worked superbly at remote transformer tapping and switching between 476 kHz and 136 kHz. So, I got the idea to put another relay above the induction coil to allow switching of the entire coil out of circuit to allow my LF/MF antenna to be used as an HF antenna as well (the LF/MF Marconi’s work great on HF)…when the aforementioned relay arced and burned from the high voltage (only about 7 kV – no big deal – hi hi), my amplifier immediately went bonkers, and the oscilloscope generated only what I can describe as an unmedicated schizophrenic waveform. Upon venturing outside to the antenna, I could immediately tell that something was amiss from the acrid fumes I detected. I was quite surprised, upon inspection of the antenna elements, to find that such a small device as an automotive relay could generate such a putrid smell that did not dissipate in the rain. The relay has since been removed and will be replaced with a Tohtsu coax relay rated for the appropriate voltage…”

courtesy N1DAY

“I also attached a picture of a florescent lamp next to my induction coil. I just had to see if that actually worked, but do not recommend the practice as it resulted in a charge on my person that was quite vigorously dissipated when I touched the metal door frame of my house after conclusion of the experiment.” That is an arc between the coil and the tube.

courtesy N1DAY

Frank, AA5IT, recently added a new amplifier to his system and reported the following fun:

I was using my amplifier tonight and it was doing well. I made about 5 transmissions on WSPR and the results were very good. All of a sudden on the 6th transmission I heard the sound of arcing noise in my stereo speakers. I looked at the SWR and if was about 25:1 so I stopped the transmission. I looked and looked but didn’t see anything wrong. I took the amp out of line and transmitted with just the transverter. Same trouble. Went out to the loading coil and discovered smoke rising from the variometer. The coil actually hits the side of the coil if I decouple it at 90 degrees. Where it was touching the PVC looked like it caught on fire.

Ken, K8HTL, showed what happens when gaps between high voltage windings and ground connections are not wide enough.

Not a lot of details on this one: N1SV reported that on Friday, December 11, 2020 just after sunset and receiving a WSPR report from LA2XPA, things stopped working. Further investigation shows an arc occurred between the hot wire and three to four of the moving coil windings. Potential difference is potential difference and the following result occurred:

courtesy N1SV

Markus, DF6NM, reported a 2200 meter coil fire. He noted that “The damage affected only some of the outer turns, so it could easily be fixed by scraping off loose carbon, and generous application of Tesa tape. The culprit was (of course) my own sloppiness: I hadn’t properly straightened the wire going horizontally from the top of the coil to the antenna uplead, such that it dangled loosely down the side of the coil until it flashed over. ” By the time I posted this entry, he was back on the air and didn’t waste any time with the repair. The before and after images follow:

courtesy DF6NM

courtesy DF6NM (larger image)

He noted in a subsequent email that “This may give you an impression of what the coil looks like. It is made from Decca Litz wire, using a stacked multilayer winding in segments of 3×8 turns. The inductance is 5 mH, and the voltage 17 kV (rms) at 4 A. The plastic stick is supposed to hold the upward wire away from the rim of the roof. The resonance is adjusted by pulling on the thin yarn near the bottom right, which rotates a 10 x 10 cm^2 ferrite slab inside the bucket.

Andy, G4JNT shares details of something that happened to him some years back.

"At one point I decided to have an ATU cabin in the garden, at the base of my Tee antenna for LF. I bought a plastic garden shed / cabinet that clipped together, but noticed it had gaps that needed to be sealed which I did aluminium tape , the stuff designed for sealing air-con ducting and the like. What I hadn't appreciated is that this stuff was thin aluminium on a plastic backing, so overlapping joints were not connected - even worse, there was a small air gap at each crossover.

I installed the 137kHz loading coil and one morning fired up the 700 Watt switch mode Tx sending a beacon signal. After perhaps an hour I smelt burning plastic, but assumed someone just had bonfire somewhere burning rubbish. Another hour later it was worse so I went out to check, and found this. It had clearly been sparking at the overlaps and ignited the slow burning polycarbonate at the base. It would have continued slow burning for a long time if I hadn't spotted it in time, being fed by melted dripping plastic dropping down.

Fortunately the 137kHz loading coil survived, but the top band ATU in the white box that had just been sitting there in the shed had to be rebuilt."

courtesy G4JNT (larger image)

courtesy G4JNT (larger image)

Marco, IK1HSS shares photos from several past experinces on 2200m:

"This was my very first antenna for 2200m. It was an inverted piramyd hang on the side of the main mast. The top PE plate (abt 2 cm thick) was providing the insulation of the antenna from the supporting pipe. All fine until a bird left a souvenir between the pipe end one of bolts."

courtesy IK1HSS

"The following antenna was a traditional T antenna stretched between 2 masts. After some time was not so stretched and the antenna wire went close to the base of the coil."

courtesy IK1HSS (larger image)

"Corona at the end of the top hat. Better to avoid metals, even with insulation, close to the high voltage antenna ends."

courtesy IK1HSS (larger image)

"Base insulator keeping the low end of the vertical wire away from the roof."

courtesy IK1HSS (larger image)

"When I tested on the antenna a new PA (600W) I noticed that something was going wrong. A visit on the roof at the switching / tuning unit reavaled that something was really wrong! I suppose an arching between the vacuum ralay switching the LF coil and the cover of the glass fiber box. The box was plenty of carbon black: the compenents inside were dirty but healty. After careful cleaning of the components and a new box all was fine. The PA is still sitting under my bed waiting for a better solution."

courtesy IK1HSS (larger image)

courtesy IK1HSS (larger image)

courtesy IK1HSS (larger image)

"Back in the past when I used a transverter as rig with a push pull amplifier. An exploded elcap and well cooked RCA jack and some ehm damaged power FET."

courtesy IK1HSS (larger image)

courtesy IK1HSS (larger image)

Dick, W7WKR, submitted the following story of RF-induced fire from back in the 1970’s. While not specifically MF or LF, it shows what can happen with high-power RF when things go very badly:

“My story goes back to late 1979 when I was living North of San Francisco and operating under an N6-additional-station (my w7wkr was still in effect) license.

I was working DX on 80-meters using a shunt-fed top loaded Rohn-25 tower. I noticed some weird behavior by my SB-220 amplifier. I looked out my shack window to see a large grass fire expanding around the tower base and knew _something_ was seriously wrong !

A fast trip to the tower accompanied by lots of stomping on burning grasses controlled the fire. The area burning was an expanding circle about 10-feet in diameter and could have easily grown to 1000’s of acres in the dry grasses. I hosed the entire area down once I suppressed the outer perimeter flames’

I dodged a serious bullet on this one! The source was a blown-up tuning unit. I beefed-up the tuner components and never had tuner failures again.”

Have images of antennas, feed line, transmitters or related items catching fire  or burning up while operating below 500 kHz? Send it to me with a description! The more dramatic, the better. Let’s be careful out there!

Last update February 10, 2021

Valid XHTML 1.0 Strict